Skip to main content

UHY Ross Brooke Chartered Accountants

Unapproved Share Option Schemes

What is an unapproved share option scheme?

An unapproved share option scheme, sometimes referred to as a non-tax-advantaged share option plan, gives an employee or director the right to acquire shares in a company at a future date at a price fixed when the option is granted.

The term “unapproved” can be slightly misleading. It does not mean that there is anything inappropriate about the arrangement, it simply distinguishes the arrangement from statutory tax-advantaged plans such as Enterprise Management Incentives (EMI), Company Share Option Plans (CSOP), Share Incentive Plans (SIP) and Save As You Earn (SAYE).

HMRC describes these statutory arrangements as ‘tax-advantaged’ or ‘approved’ schemes.

An unapproved scheme can therefore be particularly useful where a company or employee does not satisfy the conditions for EMI or another tax-advantaged arrangement, or where the company requires greater commercial flexibility than those schemes permit.

How does an unapproved share option work?

The company grants the employee an option giving them a right, but normally not an obligation, to acquire a specified number of shares.

The option agreement will set out matters such as:

  • the number and class of shares under option;
  • the price payable to acquire them;
  • when the option can be exercised;
  • any performance or service conditions;
  • what happens if the employee leaves the business; and
  • what happens on a sale, flotation or other corporate transaction.

The exercise price can be set at market value when the option is granted, at a discount to market value or, in appropriate circumstances, at nil or nominal value.

This gives unapproved options considerable flexibility. For example, they can be structured so that an employee only becomes entitled to exercise their option if the company is sold, specified financial targets are achieved or they remain with the business for a particular period.

Who can receive unapproved share options?

Unlike some tax-advantaged share schemes, there is considerable flexibility over participation. A company does not normally have to offer options to its entire workforce.

Options can therefore be targeted at particular directors and employees, making them useful for management incentive plans, senior recruitment and retention arrangements and long-term incentive plans.

They can also be considered where an employee cannot participate in EMI or CSOP because the relevant statutory eligibility requirements are not satisfied.

What happens when the option is granted?

For a straightforward employment-related securities option, there will typically be no Income Tax charge simply because the option is granted. Employment-related securities and securities options are subject to the special provisions in Part 7 ITEPA 2003. This allows the company to give an employee the opportunity to participate in future growth without the employee necessarily having to acquire shares immediately.

The precise tax position should nevertheless be considered when the scheme is designed, particularly where the option terms are unusual, the employee is internationally mobile or the option is capable of being exercised more than ten years after grant.

What happens when an option is exercised?

This is where unapproved options differ significantly from EMI and other tax-advantaged arrangements.

On exercise, the employee will generally be liable to Income Tax on the option gain.

Broadly:

Taxable option gain = market value of the shares at exercise − exercise price paid by the employee

For example, suppose an employee receives an option over 10,000 shares with an exercise price of £1 per share. When the option is exercised, the shares are worth £4 each.

The employee pays £10,000 for shares worth £40,000, producing an option gain of £30,000. Subject to the precise circumstances, that £30,000 is treated as employment income rather than a capital gain.

This is an important cash-flow consideration when options are capable of being exercised before an exit. The employee could potentially incur a tax liability while holding shares for which there is no immediate buyer.

Will National Insurance be payable?

Potentially.

The NIC and PAYE position depends particularly on whether the shares are readily convertible assets (RCAs) at the time the taxable amount arises.

Where shares are RCAs, the taxable option gain can generally be subject to PAYE and Class 1 National Insurance contributions. The RCA rules are therefore particularly important for quoted companies and where arrangements exist under which the shares can be sold or otherwise converted into cash.

HMRC’s employment-related securities legislation provides rules dealing with the Income Tax and NIC treatment of employment-related securities and options.

For private companies, the position requires careful consideration rather than assuming automatically that NIC will not arise simply because the company is unquoted. In particular, a proposed company sale or arrangements for acquiring the shares may affect the analysis.

What happens when the shares are eventually sold?

Once the option has been exercised, the employee owns the shares.

A subsequent disposal is generally within the Capital Gains Tax regime. The normal capital gains rules are modified to take account of amounts already subjected to Income Tax under the employment-related securities rules. Broadly, this prevents the same increase in value being taxed once as employment income and again as a capital gain.

For example, continuing the example above, if the employee exercises when the shares are worth £4 each and subsequently sells them for £7 each, the post-exercise growth of £3 per share would potentially fall within CGT rather than being employment income.

Other employment-related securities provisions can affect the calculation, particularly where the shares are restricted, so the position should be established when the option and share rights are designed.

Does the company get corporation tax relief?

A corporation tax deduction may be available to the employing company in respect of employee share acquisitions where the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.

Importantly, the corporation tax deduction can broadly be based upon the value transferred to the employee rather than the accounting cost of providing the shares. The timing and availability of relief should therefore be considered as part of the overall share scheme design.

Unapproved share options compared with EMI

An unapproved option can provide much greater commercial flexibility than EMI, but the employee will usually receive less favourable tax treatment.

With a qualifying EMI option granted at no less than the appropriate market value at grant, it may be possible for the growth between grant and exercise to arise without an Income Tax charge. With an unapproved option, that growth will ordinarily be employment income when the option is exercised.

The advantage of an unapproved scheme is that it is not dependent upon the company and employee satisfying the detailed EMI qualifying conditions.

This makes unapproved options particularly relevant where:

  • the company is too large or otherwise does not qualify for EMI;
  • the company’s activities prevent EMI qualification;
  • the individual does not satisfy the EMI working-time requirement;
  • employees are overseas or internationally mobile;
  • the company wants options over a class of shares or under terms that do not fit comfortably within EMI; or
  • the value to be awarded exceeds the relevant tax-advantaged scheme limits.

Exit-only options

For private companies, it is common to consider structuring options so that they become exercisable only, or primarily, when the company is sold.

An exit-only arrangement can have significant practical advantages. If exercise and sale occur at approximately the same time, the employee does not ordinarily have to fund the acquisition of shares, and potentially the associated tax liability, for a lengthy period before being able to realise their value.

Exit-only arrangements also allow existing shareholders to retain greater control over the company’s shareholder base prior to a sale.

However, the documentation and tax treatment should be considered carefully, particularly in relation to PAYE, NIC, the availability of funds to meet the exercise price and tax, and the mechanics for selling the resulting shares as part of the transaction.

Using growth shares with options

An unapproved option can also be granted over growth shares rather than the company’s existing ordinary shares.

Growth shares are designed to participate principally in increases in the value of the company above a specified threshold. This can reduce the initial value of the interest being awarded while aligning the employee’s return with future growth in the business.

Growth share arrangements require careful valuation and drafting. The rights attaching to the shares, hurdle value and treatment on an exit all affect their market value and the resulting tax treatment.

Share valuation

For unquoted companies, valuation is one of the most important aspects of establishing a share option scheme. The market value of the shares may be relevant at grant, exercise and eventual disposal. It can also affect the commercial terms of the option and the amount ultimately subject to Income Tax or CGT.

The valuation should take account of the actual rights attaching to the option shares, including voting and dividend rights, minority interests, restrictions on transfer, compulsory transfer provisions and any preferential rights attaching to other classes of shares. Simply dividing the total value of a company by the number of shares in issue will not necessarily produce the correct market value for tax purposes.

Reporting to HMRC

Although an unapproved option scheme does not require HMRC approval, this does not mean that there are no HMRC reporting requirements.

The grant, exercise, cancellation or other relevant events concerning employment-related securities may have to be reported to HMRC through the Employment Related Securities (ERS) reporting regime. Companies operating share schemes should therefore ensure that appropriate records are maintained and that the relevant annual reporting obligations are dealt with.

Is an unapproved share option scheme right for my business?

An unapproved share option plan can be a very effective way of rewarding and retaining key employees, particularly where EMI or another tax-advantaged arrangement is unavailable.

The greater flexibility does, however, come with a potential tax cost. It is therefore important to consider EMI, CSOP and other available arrangements before deciding to use an unapproved option plan. The option terms, share rights, company valuation, exercise provisions, leaver treatment, PAYE and NIC consequences, corporation tax relief and ERS reporting requirements should ideally be considered together when establishing the scheme.

How UHY Ross Brooke can help

Our tax team advises companies on the design and implementation of employee share incentives, including EMI options, CSOPs, unapproved share options, growth shares and other long-term incentive arrangements.

We can help with the initial scheme design, share valuation, tax analysis, option documentation (working with appropriately qualified lawyers) and ongoing HMRC reporting, as well as reviewing the tax consequences when options are exercised or a company is sold.

If you are considering using share options to incentivise employees or would like to discuss an existing arrangement, please contact Phil Kinzett-Evans or a member of our tax team.

Next steps

Download our guide to long term incentive plans.

UHY Ross Brooke’s tax team is experienced in share option plans, so if you have any further questions about the above or any other reward planning matters then please do not hesitate to contact Phil Kinzett-Evans.

Meet our Senior Tax Team

Michael Brooke

Director
Abingdon

Phil Kinzett-Evans crypto tax director

Phil Kinzett-Evans

Tax Director
Newbury

Tax manager for expert advice

Rebecca Horne-Smith

Associate Tax Director
Swindon

David Jones

Tax Director
Abingdon

Tom Annat, Senior tax manager, crypto tax specialist

Tom Annat

Senior Tax Manager
Abingdon

Mark Duddridge

Senior Tax Manager
Newbury

Liz Williamson

Senior Tax Manager
Abingdon

placeholder image

Mihaela Carp

Tax Manager
Abingdon

placeholder image

Richard Hill

Tax Consultant
Abingdon

What our clients say

If we did not convince you, maybe some testimonials from our customers will!

I am delighted to recommend the team at Ross Brooke. Their guidance and diligence during the acquisition phase of my business proved invaluable and continues to be so. My firm now rely upon numerous lines of their services and value their personable skills and expert knowledge. I especially appreciate their prompt response to any query raised.

Steve Cook

Rated 5 out of 5

Great service from all the team at UHY Ross-Brooke! Always very professional and courteous, it’s a real pleasure to deal with this firm. Phil Kinzett-Evans is extremely knowledgeable and was instrumental in the completion of my EOT. Tracey and Daisy have been a great help through the years with all my tax and vat affairs.

David Klein

Rated 5 out of 5

I was nervous about setting up my own company but Chris explained everything in easy terms and it was a painless undertaking. Throughout the five years as a client every transaction was painless and efficient, and always a helpful explanation or response just a phone call or e-mail away. I can highly recommend Ross-Brooke, as indeed they were recommended to me. If you’re seeking a great accountant, these are they.

Phil C

Rated 5 out of 5

Talk to us

Newbury: 01635 555666
Abingdon: 01235 251252
Swindon: 01793 610008