UHY Ross Brooke Chartered Accountants
/ Commentary / That’s never a penalty!
/ Commentary / That’s never a penalty!
Employee Share Schemes
Company Share Option Plan (CSOP)
Unapproved Share Option Schemes
Enterprise Management Incentives (EMI)
Share Incentive Plans (SIPS)
Personal Tax
Self Assessment Tax Returns
Capital Gains Tax
Tax Investigations
Inheritance Tax
Reporting CGT on Residential
EIS & SEIS Tax Relief
Property
/ Commentary / That’s never a penalty!
/ Commentary / That’s never a penalty!
That’s never a penalty!
I have been both shocked and surprised by HMRC’s latest approach to VAT penalties for deliberate error.
“But I don’t make any deliberate errors” you may think. OK, but in HMRC’s eyes you may be wrong because HMRC seem to have created their own definition of what is deliberate.
In their drive to increase revenues they now are regularly seeking deliberate error penalties of up to 70% of the tax underpaid where the taxpayer was not even aware of the error but in their view should have been. Not only is there the financial penalty but there is also the distinct possibility that the taxpayer will be publicly named and shamed.
We have recently heard of an instance where a business undertook an unusual transaction but unfortunately dealt with the VAT incorrectly. HMRC’s view was that because it was an unusual transaction the business should have taken advice. They did not and therefore their error was deliberate.
On the other hand we have heard of another case where a company dealt with many similar transactions but probably through carelessness got one wrong. HMRC view was that as the company knew the correct procedure any error must have been deliberate.
This rewriting of the encyclopaedia and Heads I Win, Tails You Lose approach seems entirely unjust and does HMRC no favours at all in the public eye. The moral of the story though must be to take professional advice whenever there is any uncertainty.
Share This Post
Related insights
New R&D tax relief guidance available
Horseracing accountant spotted at Ascot
Employment vs Self-employment?
Self-Assessment Deadlines for Tax Year 2023-2024
Tax card – rates for 2024-2025
Changes to UK company law April 2024
Payroll reminder – National Insurance rate reducing from 6 April
Increase in exemption limits for small companies
Why do I need a Shareholders’ Agreement?
Reform of non-dom taxation
Landlords – where are we now?
Intestacy Rules – Choose who you leave your estate to
Furnished holiday lets tax relief abolished – What now?
Salary sacrifice: Potentially a win-win strategy for your business and your employees
Multiple Dwellings Relief axed from 1 June 2024
Charities given new guidance on decisions about donations
High-Income Child Benefit Charge changes mean benefits for more
Spring Budget Summary 2024
What is a grant of probate and do you need one?
Trustee Bank Accounts becoming harder to access
Facing the challenges of cryptoasset taxation
Companies House fees to increase from 1 May 2024
Limited company vs Sole Trader
Tax investigations – don’t wait for HMRC to come calling
Becoming non-UK resident – can you escape the grasp of UK taxation?
Pre-April tax planning reminder
HMRC brings Double-Cab Pickup tax perk to a screeching halt
Taxation for couples – tips for 2024/25
How HMRC’s New Digital Tool Promises to Simplify Tax Relief for Work-Related Expenses
10 Tax-Efficient Investments for UK Investors
Musicians and Taxes: Hitting the right note
Act now to obtain 60% tax relief on your income
Year end tax planning summary 2024 guide
10 tax efficient ways to reward your staff
Top tips for 2023-24 year end personal tax planning
10 Simple ways to reduce your inheritance tax liability
HMRC crack-down on company owners
Am I real?
AI Opportunity Forum members now appointed
No final decision yet on a digital pound
Intending to leave a gift to the taxman of £239k?
Pension relief in more ways than one!
Five star review? Welcome news for consumers
Will I pay tax selling my old clothes online?
Tax Director explains crypto tax landscape in the FT
The 60% tax trap and how to avoid it
£851m record high tax penalties
Funding available for creative sector businesses
Important Cyber Essentials programme funding for UK businesses
UHY Prosper magazine issue 8
What charity trustees should learn from the Cat Survival Trust
Who hasn’t filed their tax return yet?
Farewell P11D – It’s been nice knowing you
Support for flood damage available
Struggling to pay your January tax?
Get ready for the Self-Assessment Deadline 2022/2023 tax year
Walk (and Bike) Oxford 2024 powered by UHY Ross Brooke
Post Office Horizon scandal: A stark reminder to prioritise people over systems
HMRC announce new disclosure campaign for crypto assets
Nothing says Christmas quite like a tax return!
Talk to us
Newbury: 01635 555666
Abingdon: 01235 251252
Swindon: 01793 610008
Hungerford: 01488 682546